Barrier free tolling is coming to the M50 and thanks to the NRA, the customer gets fleeced and the toll companies providing e-tags laugh all the way to the bank.
There are eight operators in Ireland and all of them charge a monthly fee on tags of at least one euro. A montly administration fee for what exactly? Does it buy you flexibility, i.e. the ability to register more than one car to a tag and swap the tag between cars? No. Does it offer good value for money if you aren’t a frequent user? No. The NRA does offer you the chance to pre-register for the M50 and be charged through video recognition. But this comes with a premium. A 50 cent premium each time you go under the M50 gantry.
The other alternative is the tolltag tag, that costs 30 euro and you own it outright. You have to pay an additional 10% on every toll for this privilege. You can update vehicle registration details if you change your car, but I’m not sure that you can register multiple cars to one tag. Which would be very handy for families that use the M50 infrequently and not always in the same car.
The frist time I saw e-tags in action was in Melbourne, Australia. Oh how I wish I was in Melbourne. There I can get a tag for free, provided I top it up by a minimum amount each year for the first three years. If I change my car, I do not have to order a new tag, I can just register new details. Best of all, I can register multiple cars to one tag and swap it between them.
The Melbourne model is what would be nicer for Irish consumers. You’d get your tag for free, you can register multiple tags to one account, you can move your tags between cars and after three years, you do not have to top up by a minimum amont. Thinking about how it might have worked makes me sigh. It also makes me angry that the NRA didn’t manage the e-tolling in a better, more equitable way. One supplier of tags would be preferable, the NRA and there should be no profiteering from tags, they should be break even, cost recovery only devices. After all, the whole point of them is cost recovery for the roads. Now we are forced to pay for companies to profit from the tags that enable us to use the roads.
