New search engine cuil has been released to much fanfare. Nobody seems to have written about whether it is actually any good in what I have been reading about it. Quite frankly, I think it’s probably the worst search engine I have seen. Simple queries return all sorts of irrelavant items. Search for “Dublin Hospitals” as a random example. One can assume that a person entering such a query would like a list of hospitals returned to them.
Google obliges. On my first page of links I got the following:
A-Z Hospitals in Dublin - Dublin.ie
Beaumont Hospital, Dublin, Ireland - Home Page
The Adelaide and Meath Hospital, Dublin Incorporating the National …
St Vincent’s University Hospital
Irish Statute Book, Acts of the Oireachtas, Dublin Fever Hospital …
St. James’s Hospital
Hospitals - Dublin
Bon Secours Hospital, Glasnevin,
Mater Misericordiae University Hospital-Home Page
Yahoo also obliged apart from the Ohio Health anomoly.
Dublin Hospitals
Welcome to the Dublin Hospital Section, in which we include some basic … Beaumont Hospital. Address: Beaumont Road, Dublin 9. Phone No: 01 8093000 …
www.dublinuncovered.net/hospitals.html - Cached
Hospital Information for Dublin
Dublin Uncovered Hospital Information provides general information on hospitals in Dublin such as their location and the buses that serve them.
www.dublinuncovered.net/hospital.html - Cached
A-Z Hospitals in Dublin - Dublin.ie
Beaumont Hospital, Dublin - Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia
Children’s University Hospital Temple Street
OhioHealth - Dublin Methodist Hospital
Archdiocese of Dublin - Hospitals Chaplaincies
Temple Street Childrens Hospital - Home
Cuil on the other hand -
5,449,637 results for dublin hospitals
Beaumont Hospital, Dublin
Dublin Hospitals in Dublin GA Yellow Pages by Yellow …
Irish Statute Book, Acts of the Oireachtas, Dublin …
Irish Statute Book, Acts of the Oireachtas, Dublin …
Susceptibility to antimicrobial agents and analysis …
Home @ The Mid Yorkshire NHS Trust
Dáil Éireann - Volume 79 - 06 March, 1940 - …
Irish Statute Book, Acts of the Oireachtas, Dublin …
Trinity College, Dublin
Dublin Yellow Pages and Dublin CA Guide
dublinca.areaconnect.com/
If I’m looking for information on Dublin Hospitals, I’m really not sure that Dail debates dating from the 1940s are what I’m after. Cuil only listed one hospital. Beaumont. Google and Yahoo listed a couple of the actual hospitals in Dublin. I admit google returned information about an oirechtas debate also, but it was one link only, not a couple like cuil sent me. The category returns were also quite odd. I’m searching for hospitals, and cuil thinks the tangent information I am after might include dail debates and TDs. What about Cuil for Irish users - this is the country with pretty poor broadband penetration. A lot of people still only have modems, a text only search option wouldn’t go astray. Not relevant for a company based in California, except the founders are Irish.
Like Cool? Frankly? No. It sent me running back to Google.
I like my search the way it is. I don’t want images. If I did want images in my search, then searchme leaves cool for dead. Search is about indexing. Do you get images when you look up a book in a library? No. Do you get images when you look up a name in a phonebook? No. Do you get images when you look up a word in a dictionary? No. Do you want images when you are searching for simple things (cos you are too lazy to go to the golden pages). No. Especially not when they are random images with no indication of what it is you are looking at. Like the image of the doorway or the image of a company logo.
Also, it needs to learn about inverted commas. Dublin Hospitals can be a search about Dublin and Hospitals which might explain some of the randomness returned, but “Dublin Hospitals” would (to my mind) definitely indicate that I want a concise list of hospitals in Dublin returned to me. No other information. The inverted commas made no difference, save for the fact that the search possibilities decreased to 503,904 from 3,760,623. Over three million hits for about 21 hospitals in Dublin. So, throw every possible thing that mentions Dublin and Hospital must be the approach being taken. Maybe I’m just not clever enough to get what Cuil are trying to do. But that’s fine by me. I like the simple world of Google. I’ll stay there. The privacy doesn’t bother me. Ask users of Google who don’t like their searches being recorded whether they use Gmail. If they do, then what are they worring about search privacy for?